Sign In
Learn bits
Polity & Governance
Mahesh

10/09/24 11:50 AM IST

Effective consultation

In News
  • The Supreme Court has directed the Himachal Pradesh High Court collegium to consider again the names of two judicial officers it had first recommended for elevation to the Bench 21 months ago.
Appointing Judges in High Court
  • The collegium system of appointment (and transfer) of judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts was laid down by a nine-judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association vs Union of India (1993), commonly known as the Second Judges Case.
  • The ruling made the recommendations of the SC collegium binding on the Centre, and gave the power to appoint and transfer judges of the higher judiciary to the judiciary.
  • Under the collegium system, judges choose judges — and while the government can delay their appointments, it cannot reject the collegium’s choice.
  • In 1998, in response to a series of questions from then President K R Narayanan, the SC clarified how the collegium system would function. (Third Judges Case).
  • The court said that collegiums for HC appointments would include the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the two seniormost judges of the Supreme Court.
  • This collegium would be required to consult the “Chief Justice and senior judges” of the HC concerned, the “seniormost” SC judge from that HC, as well as any SC judges who were “knowledgeable” about that HC.
  • The court also spelled out the limited grounds on which a recommendation could be challenged.
  • First, if there was lack of “effective consultation” with any of these individuals or institutions.
  • Second, if the candidate in question was not “eligible” to be a judge — these qualifications are laid down in Articles 217 (High Court) and 124 (Supreme Court) of the Constitution.
  • Following the opinion given by the SC in the Third Judges Case, the central government and the SC entered into a Memorandum of Procedure (MOP) in 1998, which detailed the process, from the beginning, for the appointment of HC judges.
  • As a part of this process, the Chief Justice of the HC must consult two other seniormost judges at the HC — together forming the High Court collegium — and send their recommendations, with reasons, to the Chief Minister, the Governor, and the CJI.
  • The Governor, based on the advice of the Chief Minister, will send the proposal to the Minister of Law and Justice at the Centre, who will conduct a background check and send the entire material to the CJI, who will consider it with the rest of the SC collegium.
Supreme Court decision
  • MAINTAINABILITY: The SC first decided whether the case fell within the SC’s narrow scope for reviewing recommendations for appointments.
  • Relying on the Second and Third judges case, the court held that this case was limited to whether there was “effective consultation” after the SC collegium’s January 4 resolution, and had “nothing to do with the ‘merits’ or the ‘suitability’ of the officers in question”.
  • PROPER PROCEDURE: The second issue was whether the HC Chief Justice individually sending a letter could qualify as “effective consultation”.
  • The court held that even though the SC collegium’s January 4 resolution was addressed to only the HC Chief Justice, “the language therein by itself cannot be understood as permitting the Chief Justice…to act on his own, in matters of recommendation or even reconsideration, for elevation to the High Court Bench”.
Source- Indian Express

More Related Current Affairs View All

12 Nov

Population decline

' The Chief Ministers of both Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu expressed concerns about the low fertility rates in their States recently.' Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N. Chandrab

Read More

12 Nov

COP 29

'As the COP29 summit begins in Baku, Azerbaijan, terms such as New Collective Quantified Goal (NCQG), the Paris Agreement, Kyoto Protocol, loss and damage, and Nationally Determine

Read More

12 Nov

Lignosat, the first wooden satellite launched into space

'The world's first wooden satellite LignoSat built by Japanese researchers was launched into space in an early test of using timber in lunar and Mars exploration.' LignoSat&rd

Read More

India’s First Ai-Driven Magazine Generator

Generate Your Custom Current Affairs Magazine using our AI in just 3 steps