Sign In
Learn bits
World Affairs
Mahesh

18/06/24 13:12 PM IST

Law on mercenaries in case of war zone

In News
  • Recently,  the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) acknowledged the tragic loss of two Indian nationals who were recruited by the Russian Army amidst the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
About Mercenaries
  • The distinction between conventional combatants and mercenaries is a fundamental cornerstone of international humanitarian law (IHL).
  • A combatant is typically a member of the armed forces of a party to the conflict, whereas a mercenary is recruited from a third-party state unrelated to the conflict.
  • Mercenaries usually engage in hostilities motivated primarily by personal gain as opposed to the virtues of patriotism associated with regular combatants.
  • Article 47 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions (API) envisages six cumulative conditions for a person to qualify as a mercenary.
  • The person i) should be specially recruited locally or abroad in order to fight in an armed conflict,
  • ii) has taken a direct part in the hostilities,
  • iii) is motivated to take part in the hostilities essentially by the desire for private gain and, in fact, is promised, by or on behalf of a party to the conflict, material compensation substantially in excess of that promised or paid to combatants of similar ranks and functions in the armed forces of that party
  •  iv) is neither a national of a party to the conflict nor a resident of territory controlled by a party to the conflict,
  • v) is not a member of the armed forces of a party to the conflict,
  • vi) has not been sent by a state which is not a party to the conflict on official duty as a member of its armed forces.
  • Under customary IHL, being a mercenary itself does not constitute a specific crime. However, if captured, mercenaries are not entitled to prisoner-of-war status or any protected categories under the Geneva Conventions.
  • This allows for their prosecution for the commission of war crimes or other grave breaches of humanitarian law.
  • They may also face charges under the domestic laws of the detaining nation. Nevertheless, mercenaries qualify for humane treatment in accordance with the fundamental guarantees of humanitarian law, as outlined under Article 75 of the API.
  • However, over time, African states began expressing reservations about this definition, as it only addressed international armed conflicts and overlooked civil wars, where mercenary activities were most prevalent.
  • This led to the adoption of the Organization of African Unity Convention for the Elimination of Mercenarism in Africa in 1977, which included a more expansive definition of mercenaries. 
  • Similarly, in 1989, the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) adopted the International Convention against the Recruitment, Use, Financing and Training of Mercenaries that criminalised the recruitment, use, financing and training of mercenaries and also promoted inter-State cooperation in this regard.
  • It also widened the definition of mercenaries as provided under the API to include “persons recruited for the purpose of participating in a concerted act of violence aimed at overthrowing a government or otherwise undermining the constitutional order of a State, or at undermining the territorial integrity of a State.” 
Challenges
  • One of the major challenges of the existing regulatory regime is the lack of a clear, unequivocal, and comprehensive legal definition of what constitutes a mercenary.
  • This is compounded by the fact that the domestic laws of most states do not criminalise mercenary activity.
  • Additionally, the definition outlined under Article 47 of the API does not include within its ambit foreign military personnel integrated into the armed forces of another state — such as the Gurkhas (soldiers from Nepal who have served in the British Army since the 1800s).
  • It also fails to establish mechanisms for holding accountable foreigners employed as advisors and trainers.
  • The  operations of the controversial Wagner Group in Russia have been increasingly subjected to international scrutiny.
  • Despite being registered as a private entity, it reportedly includes Russian army veterans among its ranks.
  • While the direct participation of the Wagner Group has been evident in the Ukraine-Russia conflict, the Kremlin had never formally acknowledged its connections with it. This has posed challenges in calling for accountability and assessing whether the group qualifies as a mercenary organisation.
  • However, following the military corporation’s aborted attempt at a coup last year, President Putin acknowledged that it had received tens of billions of roubles in public money from the government. 
  • Signatories to the Montreux Doctrine have committed to stronger state oversight of private military and security actors.
  • States are obliged to check whether PMSCs comply with international humanitarian and human rights laws.
  • However, neither India nor Russia is a signatory to this document.
  • That does not preclude India from imposing tighter restrictions on the recruitment of Indian nationals for such enterprises.
Way forward
  • The Indian government should develop a robust policy framework to address distress migration and implement strict measures against human trafficking.
  • Long-term preventive measures should target the underlying economic factors that are driving people to leave the country, while immediate measures should prioritise educating the public and ensuring strong pre-travel vetting for Indians going to Russia or other conflict zones.”
  • Pre-travel approval from the MEA for travel to Russia could be a measure to check if there are suspicious cases of human trafficking.
  • This will also enable the identification of companies that are exploiting Indians.
  • In 2012, neighbouring Bangladesh implemented the Dhaka Principles for Migration with Dignity which provides a roadmap for ethical overseas recruitment of migrants.
  • The Nepal government in January banned its citizens from travelling to Russia or Ukraine for employment after 10 young men were killed and dozens more reported missing while fighting, predominately in the Russian military. 
Source- The Hindu

More Related Current Affairs View All

15 Nov

Government issues guidelines to curb misleading ads by coaching centres

'The central Government issued new guidelines aimed at curbing misleading advertisements by coaching institutes, specifically prohibiting false promises such as "100 per cent selec

Read More

15 Nov

Janjatiya Gaurav Divas

'Every year on November 15th, Janjatiya Gaurav Divas is celebrated to honor the contributions of these communities, especially in India’s freedom struggle.' 5th November

Read More

15 Nov

Supreme Court’s order on mandatory accessibility standards

'A bench of the Supreme Court last week ordered the Union government to frame mandatory rules for ensuring the accessibility of public places and services to persons with disabilit

Read More

India’s First Ai-Driven Magazine Generator

Generate Your Custom Current Affairs Magazine using our AI in just 3 steps