Sign In
Learn bits
Polity & Governance
Mahesh

18/06/24 12:54 PM IST

Punjab & Haryana HC recommended a limit of one SIM card per person

In News
  • The Punjab and Haryana High Court urged the Centre to intensify efforts in monitoring and regulating the issuance of multiple prepaid SIM cards to individuals, amid rising cases of online fraud.
About the case
  • In ‘Sumit Nandwani vs. State of Haryana’, the court was dealing with an interim bail application from Nandwani, currently lodged in Hisar’s Central Jail.
  • The case against him dates back to last year when a man reported receiving a WhatsApp message, asking if he wanted to earn money while working from home.
  • While initial interactions with the sender included repayments that built trust and led him to make further deposits, he was eventually defrauded of over Rs 8 lakh.
  • Haryana police discovered multiple bank accounts and mobile numbers connected to the case.
  • It found that Nandwani acted as a point-of-sale agent who activated the SIM numbers used in the scam and registered them under the names of different people. He then provided them to the co-accused.
  • Nandwani reportedly obtained the prepaid SIM cards by registering them under his Aadhar card.
  • This prompted the court to ask why no government measures restrict individuals to a single pre-paid SIM card.
Law on SIM cards
  • Courts and the government have earlier restricted the sale of SIM cards without identity verification.
  • In its 2005 ruling in ‘State (NCT of Delhi) vs. Navjot Sandhu alias Afsan Guru’, the top court dealt with a matter related to the 2001 Parliament attacks.
  • In executing their plan, terrorists made a large number of calls from phones with unverified SIM cards.
  • The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) under the Ministry of Communications then issued notifications in 2006 and 2009 for banning the sale of pre-activated SIM cards.
  • Unlike pre-paid SIM cards, no ID proof or forms were required for them and they could be immediately activated after being inserted into phones.
  • However, a petitioner approached the court in 2012, saying around 80% of the pre-paid SIM cards could still be purchased in pre-activated form.
  • He also sought directions to be issued by the government for framing guidelines for telecom firms issuing SIM cards.
  • In its three-judge bench ruling in ‘Avishek Goenka vs. Union of India’ (2012), the SC directed the constitution of a joint expert committee and asked it to submit a response to the government.
  • Nearly four months later, the Telecom Ministry issued instructions by way of a circular, saying that an individual category customer (i.e., local, outstation, and foreign) can subscribe to “a maximum of nine mobile connections” in his or her name across all telecom service providers and Licensed Service Areas (LSAs).
  • For people in Jammu and Kashmir, Assam, and the Northeast LSAs the limit was set at six connections.
  • It also said that while filling out the customer application forms, individuals must provide a declaration about the connections already held.
Issues
  • While linking ID cards to phones may seem like a possible security solution, it involves significant privacy and compliance issues.
  • These instructions (on limiting the number of mobile connections) emerged from the government’s licensing power, but there exists a lack of pro-active scrutiny and audit of practices by telecom companies.”
  • Referring to the Supreme Court’s decision in ‘KS Puttaswamy vs Union of India’ (2018), which upheld the fundamental right to privacy, Gupta also pointed out that linking Aadhar with SIM cards is not mandatory.
  • Aadhar is only one of the identity documents an individual can provide.
  • Delhi-based lawyer Radhika Roy said that despite the clear mandate laid down in the Puttaswamy case, saying there shall be no mandatory linking of Aadhar with SIM cards, the recent Telecommunications Act of 2023 mentioned it.
Source- The Hindu

More Related Current Affairs View All

15 Nov

Government issues guidelines to curb misleading ads by coaching centres

'The central Government issued new guidelines aimed at curbing misleading advertisements by coaching institutes, specifically prohibiting false promises such as "100 per cent selec

Read More

15 Nov

Janjatiya Gaurav Divas

'Every year on November 15th, Janjatiya Gaurav Divas is celebrated to honor the contributions of these communities, especially in India’s freedom struggle.' 5th November

Read More

15 Nov

Supreme Court’s order on mandatory accessibility standards

'A bench of the Supreme Court last week ordered the Union government to frame mandatory rules for ensuring the accessibility of public places and services to persons with disabilit

Read More

India’s First Ai-Driven Magazine Generator

Generate Your Custom Current Affairs Magazine using our AI in just 3 steps